Part 3: Bristol Bay, Trolls, and the Pebble Mine
The third and final post of this blog series focuses on a concentration of wild rivers located in Bristol Bay at the northeastern end of the Alaskan peninsula. This watershed supports the world’s largest sockeye salmon fishery, accounting for approximately 46% of the average global numbers of these wild fish. Almost half of the Bristol Bay sockeye salmon production is from the Nushagak River and Kvichak River watersheds, the largest of Bristol Bay’s six major river basins. These pristine areas are teaming with an abundance of fish and wildlife. They are also located near huge copper, gold, and molybdenum mineral deposits.
The Pebble Mine Project in Alaska has been a hot topic of controversy for many years. The first two exploration holes were drilled in 1988, and in 1989 twelve more drill holes, soil sampling, and geophysical survey were completed. The land is owned by the State of Alaska, and mineral rights are held by Pebble Mines Corporation.
The Pebble Mine project appeared on my radar a few years ago and I have been following it for quite some time. Recently, I reposted a comment on Twitter by the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC is a group of law students and attorneys at the forefront of the environmental movement.) My repost was immediately hammered by trolls, and the comments were ugly, to say the least. Constructive discussion and lively debate were definitely not on their agenda—it was a full-blown personal attack. Several comments stated, “do your due diligence.” This became motivation to dig even deeper into this controversy and analyze the players.
Proponents argue that the mine will create jobs, provide tax revenue to the state of Alaska, and reduce American dependence on foreign sources of raw materials. Supporters point to the Pebble Project Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) presented by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. The major players include many pro-business state officials, and an international mining corporation in search of investors. In 2018, then Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Administrator Scott Pruitt supported the project before he stepped down from his position due to a series of scandals.
Opponents argue that the mine would adversely affect the entire Bristol Bay watershed. They consider the possible consequences to fish populations, when mining effluents escape containments, are simply too great of a risk. Local tribes and commercial fishermen fear the mine could destroy one of the world’s most prolific salmon runs. Thirteen tribes that make up the United Tribes of Bristol Bay, have joined efforts with commercial fisherman, environmental groups, and the EPA to fight against development of the Pebble Mine.
The Alaska Native cultures of the Nushagak River and Kvichak River watersheds— the Yup’ik and Dena’ina—are two of the last intact, sustainable salmon-based cultures in the world. Salmon are integral to their way of life as subsistence food, and as the foundation for their language, spirituality, and social structure.
For commercial fisherman, the sockeye salmon migration into Bristol Bay often exceeds forty million fish. As they migrate into the Kvichak and Nushagak rivers, and travel into tributaries, the sockeye and four other species of Pacific salmon are pursued by commercial and sport fisheries. The value of these industries exceeds half a billion dollars.
The state needs jobs, and the Pebble mine could create more than 3,000 positions. The fishing industry, however, supports 14,000 jobs. Damage to the Bristol Bay watershed would be devastating, both environmentally and economically. The world also needs copper, gold, and other metals. Manufacturing, including new green efforts that focus on solar and wind power, depend on these materials, as well as technological industries. A balance can be struck between mining and environmental concerns, and in many places, this has been proven to be true.
The big question remains: is the largest sockeye salmon fishery in the world, and one of the last regions of wild rivers, the best location for mining?
Two important dates are only a few days away. A comment period for the Pebble Mine Project ends July 1st. You can submit your comment here, or click here for more information. Ironically, July 4th marks the peak of the largest, most valuable, wild salmon run left in America.
June 26, 2019
Trout Unlimited Criticizes Initial Step by EPA to Remove Proposed Bristol Bay Protections.
CLICK HERE for full story.
June 19, 2019
The House of Representatives took dramatic and much needed action today by passing amendment #90 to the Energy and Water Appropriations Act (H.R. 2740) bill. If passed by both chambers of Congress and signed by the President, the amendment would prohibit the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers from using funds to issue a permit for the proposed Pebble Mine.
CLICK HERE for full story.
Army Corp of Engineers EIS: CLICK HERE
Commercial Fishing in Bristol Bay: CLICK HERE
National Geographic: CLICK HERE
Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC): CLICK HERE
Seven Bristol Bay Facts: CLICK HERE
United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA): CLICK HERE
United Tribes of Bristol Bay: CLICK HERE
• Feature photo by USEPA (United States Environmental Protection Agency)
Aerial view of braided wetlands and tundra that is typical of the Bristol Bay watershed in Alaska. Upper Talarik Creek (shown in photo) flows into Lake Iliamna and then the Kvichak River before emptying into Bristol Bay. This image is a work of an EPA employee, taken or made as part of that person’s official duties. As works of the U.S. federal government, all EPA images are in the public domain.
• Mulchatna River, by USEPA
• Exploratory rig, by Erin McKittric
Pebble Mine site photos by Erin McKittrick: CLICK HERE
• Spawning male sockeye, by USEPA
Photo courtesy of Thomas Quinn, University of Washington
• Brown bear, by Brian W. Schaller
Fine essay Bruce. Thanks for putting the spotlight on this important issue.
Thank you, Randy. There is a lot of information about this project so I tried to summarize as best as I could. It’s very complex, but when analyzing the concerns of local residents, tribal members, environmental organizations, and fishermen, the clearer the picture becomes. I’ll be sharing more information on later posts, but it’s going to take some time to see where all this is headed. Public opinion will be closing on Monday, and comments can be submitted here: https://pebbleprojecteis.com
Hi my name is Diana Ramstad and I am Stu Ramstad’s Daughter, I am writing to you to say that I am against the Pebble mine. My Father Stuart Ramstad built Little Mulchatna Lodge on Fish trap lake on the Little Mulchatna river.
Thank you so much for the comment, Diana. I looked up the Little Mulchatna Lodge online — what a magnificent location and rich history. I’m following the Pebble Mine situation and my thoughts are with all of the communities that could be affected by this proposed project. I hope that local residents like yourself know that you are not alone in your fight to protect this area. I recently viewed this video: https://youtu.be/qhb8fb5pBvc